Search This Blog

Sunday, April 6, 2025

1e, str limits by race and gender; psionics

 So much common sense stuff was in adnd 1e. I remember being annoyed at … was it the first book of BECMI or 2e or 3e(?) (or just my incorrect friends ) where a halfling could have max strength. Pretty sure 3.5e at least did a -2 str and plus 2 dex for them or something. 

Via Willy Muffin’s yt “review- advanced dungeons & dragons 1st edition” : at time 36:50

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S1GaEOmYYSs

Strength Table I.

14 was max str possible for a female halfling character 

15 was max str poss for a female gnome character 

At time 43:45 talks about min 12 CON for dwarfs etc  Then takes the “just ignore the male female limits stuff… misogyny”. Well… there is a level of realism there, it’s not anti-female just physics, so… seems ok to me. I mean a female character could get a magical device to get super strength and thatd make sense. 

 

—-

Paionics analysis at time 41:00, and it was stolen for adnd from “Eldrich Wizardry” he says. 

—-

Unearthed Arcana pros and cons at about time 1:03:00 to 1:05:00. Cavaliers for example. And much earlier he said paladines were probably overpowered too. 

—-

Near end, says adnd DMGuide is best for allveraions. The tables for inspiration. The Appendix N list of classic fantasy novels and books. 


Monster Melee results- Beholder vs Orcs

 The crazy faced 1e MM beholder mini vs. a large group of orcs. Had one war chief, 3 shamans (eye of grumpsh), one blade of xyz, … and 3 that were just dbl hp and dbl attacks, then 7 or 8 regular guys, one war drummer (ability to give one orc a reaction att… we made it up). 


Beholder was rushed down and couldn’t fly up so cornered. Right before dead, he charmed the warchief. Turned into a very funny roleplay stiey where the warchief called off all the attackers and they left. 

One lone grey orc was knocked out, left behind. The beholder got him, with that cray smile. 

Saturday, April 5, 2025

Captcorajus’s 4e video has good info

 Time 7:23, on yt, has list of dns clones from around year 2014.

Osric

Labyrinth Lord

Dungeon Crawl Classics (has a new type of magic also, has some tables makes it a little complex, … see other guys video of 3 things DCC does better than DnD, and 3 not so much)

Basic Fantasy- i bought it. Pretty cool but way too simple. 

Swords and Wizardry

Castles and Crusades

Dark Dungeons 

Sly Flourish house rules for 5e

 Some seem good. Some r just nerfs.  Consider

Animate objects is max 4 objects… nerf  hmmm  

Arcane eye not inviz, has v good stealth. 

Counterspell… if u get counter soelled, u can cast a new lower lvl spell as reaction (((i might switch to cantrip)))

Heat metal- doesn’t cause disav on att rolls (too nerfy)

Wall force or force cage- dex save to avoid trapped  nerf  Dmg can take down wall?! Huge nerf  

… ok keep watching bcuz good arguments… and he tweaked the nerfs to be less severe and more about boss monsters  


See this for 2024 spell changes, similar. Like Counterspell wont waste a slot.  

https://www.wargamer.com/dnd/changes-to-spells-2024-players-handbook



Thursday, April 3, 2025

X-Files, Clyde Buckman’s Final Repose

 Season 3 ep 4.  We just watched (rewatched at least for me). 

Rly good.  Funny parts, but sad. Kinda deep.  Wikiped talks about it ALot.. many ppls fav or top 5 episode.  

Fan trivia… even tho he says Scully never dies, it was bcu he liked her.  But bcuz fans went nuts, later they rly made her immortal.  See wikiped.


But what I wanted to figure out was, why at the end did Scully see him normally (dead), but then saw him under plastic, with the tear and/or water.  ?  I think it was some kinda psychic stuff.  


Me n the kid have theories.  She got the “woman’s intuition “ maybe right when Clyde dies… like it passed to her.  His psychic stuff went to her.  Ofciurse she doesnt see dead ppl, but close enough.  

She saved Mulder, how? Her woman’s intuition.  

Devastate a great 2e dnd spell

See page121 yt about it.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OPcn0Kd_VCQ

Level 8 spell. 1 round per level duration. https://adnd2e.fandom.com/wiki/Devastate_(Wizard_Spell)

Cast on self, now your spells are buffed for that many rounds… 

  • -5 penalty to enemy saving throw.
  • +2 to dmg on each die of your spell, but can't do more than normal max (ex., 60 normal dmg max as in 10d6 the fireball limit in 2e).  
    • which reminds me of https://www.enworld.org/threads/fireball-throughout-the-ages.670886/
      • Amazing how the damage drops on average over the editions*...

        OD&D - d6/level
        Expert - d6/level save for half
        1e - d6/level save for half
        2e - d6/level save for half, capped at 10d6
        3e - d6/level save for half capped at 10d6 (metamagics could boost initial damage)
        4e - 3d6 + Int modifier, save for half (metamagics could increase number of damage dice)
        5e - 8d6 save for half (metamagics could increase number of damage dice)

        ...while at the same time everybody's - monster and PC alike - hit points generally increase.
      • * - the exception beng 5e, which - rather oddly - has the highest damage of all for casters of 5th-7th level yet by 9th caster level, absent metamagics, has lower damage than any other version except 4e.

        Another big difference is that in 2e and earlier the fireball expanded to fill its entire volume, where in 3e and later it doesn't. (((AKA weaker but easier to control and calculate)))
      • More info: https://deltasdnd.blogspot.com/2011/07/spells-through-ages-fireball.html
        • So RULES CYCLOPEDIA after 2e, caps dmg at 20d6. Interesting, is that one place where it actually went back up in dmg? 
          • Figured I'd check in here on the 1990 Allston Rules Cyclopedia product, representing the culmination of the whole Moldvay (B/X)/Mentzer (BXCMI) product line.
          • Finally, something else that was added to the spell description (at the end of the second paragraph above) is a mechanic to try and restrict shooting fireballs through arrow slits. However, I found that in practice that this was not very much of an effective restriction in 3E (motionless target ACs are very low, and fireball-casting wizard attack levels with Dexterity bonus quite high, which along with a lack of any ranged penalties for the spell, made for an almost trivially easy to-hit requirement).
      • Orig orig: https://www.enworld.org/threads/the-fireball-spell-through-the-editions.169729/
Page121 made the point that it is not in the PHB, it's not even in 1e, but he felt it was great to introduce as loot around a level 16 (I think he said 16) MagicUser b/c too many things are a 50/50 coin toss with strong saving throws around that level. 

Wednesday, April 2, 2025

Pathfinder stuff - about Deflection Bonus. About Pathfinder 1e Vs. Pathfinder 2e.

BTW, path2e rules for spell saves vs, a DC, a 10 below the dc is critical fail take dbl dmg, a 10 above is critical success zero dmg.  (A nat 20 or a nat 1 increases or descreases one step further) Think about it both ways tho.  Vs baddies, or them vs party.  Exciting for sure  

AND, COVER… only +1 AC for creature in way.  +2 for standard cover, and object in the environment.  Come to think about it, is +2 AC for ranged into melee way too muchin 5e? Since AC is so low? 

UPDATE: Just bought the Pathfinder 2e beginner Box. Is really is that good. And I like the fact that the little handout cards are mostly just the differences between Pathfinder 2e and DnD5e. 

  • Heard that they have the BEST modules to play
  • I already have a million of their flip maps, super good. 
  • Those new minis were pathfinder


  So I was just thinking about how in dnd 5e, you cant get but +2 AC total from stacking a ring of protec and cloak of protect. 



The answer, is that in Pathfinder-

  • You cannot stack Deflection bonuses
    • Deflection bonuses are from magic
  • But there is no Cloak of Protection anyway, it would seem. Only cloaks of Resistance. 
Quote on a few interesting ones from Pathfinder (thinking back to 3.5e dnd days):

  • Deflection bonus; usually up to +5 and can be obtained via Ring of ProtectionShield of Faith, and various Protection from Alignment spells; covers both Flat-Footed and Touch AC.

  • Dodge; various abilities and the Feat Dodge gives you a Dodge bonus; covers Touch AC; stacks.



So, Pathfinder 1e vs. 2e




I agree with wingnut. There is less you can do in combat in 2E. Most fights are going to be apply simple debuff, make attacks until enemy dies. If an enemy has high AC you, can't do much about it. You can't try to attack from different angles by targeting touch AC or CMD. Even if you use combat maneuvers most of their debuffs don't stack, so you can't overcome the situation without damage.

Example from a recent 2E game. We had a tough enemy prone, flanked, and feinted, but all this amounted to was they were flatfooted. If this was 1E they would have lost their DEX mod to AC/CMD, taken a -4 penalty vs melee, and you would have gained a +2 bonus to hit them.

REBUKE: 

Most fights are going to be apply simple debuff, make attacks until enemy dies.

I'm glad you haven't played at any of my tables, I never advice new players to do simple tactics because I will kill them if they do stuff like this.

You can't try to attack from different angles by targeting touch AC or CMD.

This actually isn't accurate. You can attack Fort DC or Reflex DC or Will DC with combat maneuvers, so you get much more angles to attack than simply CMD.

Even if you use combat maneuvers most of their debuffs don't stack

Yes and no. Flat Footed doesn't stack, but being flat footed and frightened does. So you have to be diverse in your debuffs to get them to stack and not simple.

We had a tough enemy prone, flanked, and feinted, but all this amounted to was they were flatfooted.

prone and flanked do amazing things that you don't seem to realize. A prone enemy has to spend an action to get up to not suffer a penalty to attack. 2e focuses more on efficiency of actions and an action not spent trying to kill the PC is good for the PC. The Feint probably should have been a disarm attempt or demoralize.




NOTE: Combat Maneuver Defense (CMD) in Pathfinder is a measure of a character's ability to resist combat maneuvers like grappling or tripping. It is calculated using the formula: CMD = 10 + Base Attack Bonus + Strength modifier + Dexterity modifier + special size modifier + any applicable bonuses or penalties.

http://www.tenebraemush.net/index.php/Understanding_CMB_and_CMD

Your CMB

 
CMB = BAB + STR + Size Mod + Other

Your CMD

 
CMD = 10 + BAB + STR + DEX + Size Mod + Other


Scuttlebutt, parish-pump, furphy, the water cooler, the coffee area

Funnily, all these terms are related to a place people hang out and talk/gossip. It's always around a communal drinking area. 

parish-pump

  • It was an old fashioned water pump shared by locals. 
  • Now it means only important or interesting to people in a small area.

scuttlebutt =  

  • Rumor or gossip is the meaning now. 
  • It was a sailor thing -> a drinking fountain or a cask of drinking water on a ship.

furphy

  • a false report, Australian slang. 
  •   From John Furphy, an Australian blacksmith and engineer, who designed a galvanised iron water-cart on wheels, displaying the name FURPHY in large letters. In World War I the Army bought many Furphy water and sanitation carts for camps in Palestine, Egypt. and Australia. When soldiers gathered around them, the carts became centers of gossip. The word scuttlebutt originated in a similar way.

  • "Bookmakers are confident in the integrity of the AFL and the security used to guard the Brownlow Medal votes, believing any leaks are mere gossip and unfounded. Centrebet spokesman Gerard Daffy said last week's leak tipping St Kilda midfielder Robert Harvey winning a third Brownlow was a furphy."
    Darren Cartwright; Voss Still Brownlow Favourite; Fox Sports; Sep 18, 2003.
    "If it is proved that the bugs originated from space, then the damage to the ozone layer may also have originated from space. This will render the ozone theory a furphy."
    Rob Horne; Bugs in Space?; The Advertiser (Adelaide, Australia); Aug 3, 2001.  

https://wordsmith.org/words/scuttlebutt.html

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/parish-pump

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/furphy

https://wordsmith.org/words/furphy.html

Tuesday, April 1, 2025

Min Max Stuff...

 I dunno if I should read this. Stuff about 5.5e, paralyze and chromatic orb. ... ....


https://www.enworld.org/threads/the-bg3-effect-control-and-paralyzing-5-5-meta.712563/

Funny (scary) quote - Terry Pratchett, Hogfather... (Death)

Thanks to https://www.enworld.org/threads/the-d-d-memes-thread.693664/page-11 for leading me to this quote.  


Hogfather Quotes Showing 1-30 of 365
“All right," said Susan. "I'm not stupid. You're saying humans need... fantasies to make life bearable."

REALLY? AS IF IT WAS SOME KIND OF PINK PILL? NO. HUMANS NEED FANTASY TO BE HUMAN. TO BE THE PLACE WHERE THE FALLING ANGEL MEETS THE RISING APE.

"Tooth fairies? Hogfathers? Little—"

YES. AS PRACTICE. YOU HAVE TO START OUT LEARNING TO BELIEVE THE LITTLE LIES.

"So we can believe the big ones?"

YES. JUSTICE. MERCY. DUTY. THAT SORT OF THING.

"They're not the same at all!"

YOU THINK SO? THEN TAKE THE UNIVERSE AND GRIND IT DOWN TO THE FINEST POWDER AND SIEVE IT THROUGH THE FINEST SIEVE AND THEN SHOW ME ONE ATOM OF JUSTICE, ONE MOLECULE OF MERCY. AND YET—Death waved a hand. AND YET YOU ACT AS IF THERE IS SOME IDEAL ORDER IN THE WORLD, AS IF THERE IS SOME...SOME RIGHTNESS IN THE UNIVERSE BY WHICH IT MAY BE JUDGED.

"Yes, but people have got to believe that, or what's the point—"

MY POINT EXACTLY.”
― Terry Pratchett, Hogfather